Friday, 20 November 2026

The Things We Inherited Without Learning To Make

I have spent half my life in Bengal

and the other half in Bangalore.

Long enough to acquire two geographies,

not long enough to stop being a stranger

in either.


In Bengal, a story could be carried

rolled beneath an arm.

A Patua would unfurl a pata,

one frame at a time,

and sing what the pigments could not say.

Pater gaan.

The song moved at the speed of the scroll,

the scroll at the mercy of the song.

Mythology, folklore, a god's misfortunes,

the latest disaster in the human republic.

Even the news could be painted

before anyone thought to call it content.


In Naya, Pingla,

the scrolls still enter the world.

Some are made for walls now,

some for visitors, fairs, collectors.

The old songs have not entirely surrendered

to the new subjects.

There are still voices willing to unfurl them.

Once, a performance travelled

from household to household;

now the household is the destination,

and the song something

a visitor must ask for.


I know the difference

between a story being available

and a story being told.


In Karnataka, stories require a screen.

Togalu Gombeyaata:

cattle hide cleaned, tanned,

chiselled into gods and demons,

perforated until light bleeds

through the body of a deity.

A bamboo split gives the figure bone.

A lamp gives it a shadow.

Someone gives it a voice.


The night begins with Ganesha

and Saraswati.

Then Killekyata and Bangarakka arrive,

with the indecency of comic relief,

as if even the gods require

someone to puncture their importance.


The epics wait their turn.

The dhol, the mukhavina, the cymbals.

Ten o'clock until the morning

has no choice but to inherit it.


I like to imagine Bangarakka

knows more about survival

than the gods she interrupts.


Oil lamps have given way to bulbs.

Puppets have acquired hinged limbs.

Natural pigments have grown scarce,

performing troupes fewer.

The changes are not all betrayals.

An art that refuses to bend

may have no audience left to disappoint.


I am careful with that last line.

It sounds like something

a room might applaud.


I recognise myself

in these mechanics.

I, too, make dead things speak.

I give the past dialogue,

the living a motive,

the unsayable a microphone.

I have stood beneath stage lights

and mistaken being seen

for being understood.

I have made strangers laugh

at the exact things they came to avoid.


But I cannot grind a pigment.

I cannot cut a god out of hide.

I cannot sing a story

into the specific shape of its unfolding.

I know enough to borrow the names,

the images, the impending silence.


Which is perhaps

the most lucrative form of inheritance:

knowing what something means

without knowing how to make it.


I write about the Patua

and the puppeteer.

Someone reads.

Someone feels a little less ignorant.

Someone shares the poem.

The disappearing becomes legible,

the legible becomes moving,

the moving becomes mine.


I have turned their shrinking rooms

into a crowd of my own.


There is a word for what remains

when a tradition is reduced

to what can be carried away.

A scroll without its song.

A puppet without its screen.

A performance stripped of the people

who know when to improvise,

when to interrupt,

when a room has heard enough

and when it has not heard nearly enough.


We preserve the objects.

We photograph the hands.

We archive the songs.

We build a stage for the last practitioner

and ask for one more demonstration.


Then we applaud.


I have spent half my life in Bengal

and half in Bangalore.

Between them, I have gathered

enough stories to keep telling

and not enough craft

to keep either world alive.


Tomorrow, perhaps,

someone will catalogue my books,

annotate my manuscripts,

write that I belonged to two cities

and gave their contradictions a voice.


I wonder what will be left

when the voice is severed from the body,

the story from its telling,

the shadow from the hand

that knows how to move it.


I could write another poem about that.


I probably will.

There is, after all,

still an audience for things

that are disappearing.

No comments:

Post a Comment